Esther Planas
Copyright 2023
new news new news new news new news
>>
August/September 2025
Summer/Fall Reading Group: Views from Palestine
We want to not just read about Palestine, but read material by Palestinian theoreticians and scholars. We hope to engage with these thinkers and learn the ways that they have developed the broad tradition of critical thought in pursuit of liberation.
The reading group will last six weeks. We will start with Ghassan Kanafani’s seminal book On Zionist Literature, followed by two very recent publications: the suppressed text on the “Nakba as a Legal Concept” by Rabea Eghbariah, and, to conclude, the recently published Resisting Erasure by Adam Hanieh, Robert Knox, and Rafeef Ziadah. (Supplementary readings will be available through our Discord server and emailed to participants in advance of the meetings.)
September 6 — “Toward the Nakba as a Legal Concept” by Rabea Eghbariah (presented by Esther Planas Balduz and Morgan Lily)
Description: Rabea Eghbariah’s “Toward Nakba as a Legal Concept” is an essay that has, in a way, performed itself. Originally solicited, edited, and approved by the Harvard Law Review, its publication was subsequently vetoed by the leadership of the journal. Displaced, the article was taken in by the Columbia Law Review. But here too it found itself ultimately unwelcome, as upon publication the entire Columbia Law Review website was shut down by the Review’s board in a vain attempt at suppression. The simple, forceful, and comprehensively put argument that warranted such suppression is this: the law and legal theory lack the language to speak the reality of the Palestinian condition and therefore leave it unable to properly recognise both the existence of the Palestinian people and the crimes committed against them by the so-called state of Israel. This condition, Eghbariah argues, is best captured through the concept of Nakba (Catastrophe) and its ideological counterpart—Zionism.
Full Program: https://ctwgwebsite.github.io/news/announcement_9/
Primary Reading:
Eghbariah, “Toward the Nakba as a Legal Concept;” Introduction, Sections I-II (pp. 888-955; 67 pages)
March 2025
Spring Reading Group: The Science of Society in Critical Theory
Our upcoming reading group session begins on Saturday, March 22. Meeting weekly on Saturdays at 12:00 PM Eastern Time, it will comprise seven sessions over the course of eight weeks. The sessions are as follows:
March 22 — Class, Monopolies, and Rackets: “On The Sociology of Class Relations” by Max Horkheimer (presented by Re Tejus)
March 29 — Rackets, Monopolies, and Imperialism: Texts by Horkheimer and Milios and Sotiropoulos (presented by Mac Parker)
April 5 — The Origins of Mechanical Explanation: “The Social and Economic Roots of Newton’s Principia” by Boris Hessen (presented by Anatarah bin AlKaf)
April 12 — Historical Materialism and Nature: Texts by Karl August Wittfogel (presented by J. E. Morain)
April 19 — No meeting
April 26 — The Polymorphous Psyche of Bourgeois Society: “Egoism and Freedom Movements” by Max Horkheimer (presented by Esther Planas Balduz)
May 3 — Revolution and Rhetoric in Modernity: Texts by Max Horkheimer (presented by James Crane)
MARGIN NOTES V1, “KERNELS OF EARLY CRITICAL THEORY”
Reconstruction & reevaluation of the “esoteric,” Marxian core of 1930s critical theory: critique of political economy as the struggle for self-consciousness in late capitalism.
With articles by the Critical Theory Working Group editorial board.
Critical Theory Working Group, Summer 2024 Reading Group: The Fight for the Dialectic of Enlightenment
Session 4. June 22nd, “Excursus II: Juliette or Enlightenment and Morality” (Esther Planas Balduz)
November-December 2023
Critical Theory Working Group
Saturday, December 9th – Selections from: Horkheimer, “Materialism and Morality” (1933) and “Materialism and Metaphysics” (1933). Introduction and Discussion by Esther Planas Balduz.
April 2023
Five Years Study Group Fragments for an Antifascist Newsletter at Five Years, Sunday 23rd April 2023
http://fiveyears.org.uk/archive2/pages/306/FY_Study%20Group/306.html
Sept 2022
REFUGIA
Part 3
Exhibition
.............
March/April 2022
Establecimientos Naturales: Esther Planas y Stephane Carpinelli Espacio 88, Barcelona, Catalonia.
June 2021
Awarded grant for foreign studies OSIC, Generalitat de Catalunya for studies abroad/Beques per a la formació i el perfeccionament en els àmbits de les arts visuals, dels nous sectors creatius, de les arts escèniques, de la música i del pensament, 2020/2021
March 2021
Q&A with Five Years new member Esi Eshun about her new work The Unbecoming, which is included
in the work for the UOC as part of my work on subaltern studies, critical race, and urban interventions
http://fiveyears.org.uk/archive2/pages/286/The_Unbecoming/286.html
February 2021
MayDay Rooms' Events: Let a thousand A4 pages bloom: the newsletter from past and present!
February 2020
Artist-Run Spaces: Esther Planas from Five Years at Associates Space, at Spike Island, Bristol https://www.spikeisland.org.uk/our-community/spike-associates/?fbclid=IwAR1R99JXH4OZZm81eJPpN-ZqbCx7vmpHZGa9zn-yhFBDufW70X685W32ms4